Weld County, Colorado

Greeley --° Loading NWS
Claim your listing

Restaurants · Gilcrest

Best Restaurants in Gilcrest, CO

4 restaurants ranked by Google rating and review volume. Updated October 2026.

4Listed
4.7Avg rating
564Reviews

Showing 4 of 4

  1. 1. La Cocina Mexicana Restaurant

    ★★★★★ 4.8 (77 Google reviews)

    Mexican Restaurant · $10-20 · 645 Railroad St, Gilcrest

    TakeoutKid friendly

    "This is the BEST Mexican food you will ever have outside of your grandma's house!!! The smothered burrito is worth three first born children! But really... Every time I visit Colorado, this..."

    Crystal Zapata on Google
  2. 2. Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

    ★★★★★ 4.6 (248 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $20-30 · 801 Railroad St, Gilcrest

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Stopped on a whim an glad we did! We had pleasant staff assist us right as we walked in. Food was fresh an ready quickly. smiling faces delivered our food which was scrumptious! They..."

    Shannon H. on Google
  3. 3. Carniceria Mexico

    ★★★★★ 4.5 (233 Google reviews)

    Mexican Restaurant · $10-20 · 905 Railroad St, Gilcrest

    TakeoutKid friendly

    "My favorite lunch spot. Corner store, meat market and restaurant all in one."

    Kizzy Vieux on Google
  4. 4. Rico Burritos

    ★★★★★ 4.8 (6 Google reviews)

    Burrito Restaurant · $1-10 · 905 Railroad St, Gilcrest

    TakeoutKid friendly

    "My favorite burrito spot. Can't drive by without stopping."

    Marc Keller on Google

Restaurants in Gilcrest, CO at a glance

We track 4 restaurants in Gilcrest, CO, carrying 564 Google reviews between them and an average rating of 4.7 stars. La Cocina Mexicana Restaurant holds the strongest rating among well reviewed spots at 4.8 stars, while Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop is the most reviewed with 248 reviews.

1 stay open past 9 p.m. on at least one night, which helps if you are eating after a game or a late shift. 2 keep Sunday hours. According to Google, 4 list takeout and 4 list kid friendly.

Several cluster along Railroad St, so you can compare a couple of options in one trip. Where Google lists a price level, $ is the most common at 3 of 4 listings.

Questions people ask about restaurants in Gilcrest

What is the best rated restaurant in Gilcrest, CO?

La Cocina Mexicana Restaurant has the highest rating among restaurants in Gilcrest, CO with at least 25 Google reviews, at 4.8 stars from 77 reviews.

Which restaurant in Gilcrest, CO has the most reviews?

Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop has the most Google reviews of any restaurant in Gilcrest, CO, with 248 reviews and a 4.6 star average.

Which restaurants in Gilcrest, CO are open late?

1 restaurants in Gilcrest, CO stay open past 9 p.m. on at least one night, including Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop.

Do any restaurants in Gilcrest, CO deliver?

Google lists delivery for 1 restaurants in Gilcrest, CO, including Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop.

Listing data, ratings, reviews and photos provided by . Photos remain the property of their credited authors.