Weld County, Colorado

Greeley --° Loading NWS
Claim your listing

Restaurants · Keenesburg

Best Bakeries & Desserts in Keenesburg, CO

2 bakeries & desserts ranked by Google rating and review volume. Updated October 2026.

2Listed
4.9Avg rating
383Reviews

Showing 2 of 2

  1. 1. Wild Animal Sanctuary Cafe & Ice Cream Shop

    ★★★★★ 4.8 (382 Google reviews)

    Ice Cream Shop · 2999 Co Rd 53, Keenesburg

    Kid friendly

    "What a wonderful place! It’s a short drive from Denver and worth the trip to be part of such a great cause. The welcoming staff was so happy and informative. The 30ft raised walkway through..."

    Amy Wolfe on Google
  2. 2. Maritza Bakery

    ★★★★★ 5.0 (1 Google reviews)

    Bakery · 75 Crawford Ave, Keenesburg

    Takeout

    "Good quality"

    Otis Fellows on Google

Bakeries & Desserts in Keenesburg, CO at a glance

We track 2 bakeries & desserts in Keenesburg, CO, carrying 383 Google reviews between them and an average rating of 4.9 stars. Wild Animal Sanctuary Cafe & Ice Cream Shop leads on both counts, with a 4.8 rating across 382 reviews.

1 keep Sunday hours.

Questions people ask about bakeries & desserts in Keenesburg

What is the best rated bakery or dessert shop in Keenesburg, CO?

Wild Animal Sanctuary Cafe & Ice Cream Shop has the highest rating among bakeries & desserts in Keenesburg, CO with at least 25 Google reviews, at 4.8 stars from 382 reviews.

Which bakery or dessert shop in Keenesburg, CO has the most reviews?

Wild Animal Sanctuary Cafe & Ice Cream Shop has the most Google reviews of any bakery or dessert shop in Keenesburg, CO, with 382 reviews and a 4.8 star average.

Listing data, ratings, reviews and photos provided by . Photos remain the property of their credited authors.