Weld County, Colorado

Greeley --° Loading NWS
Claim your listing

Restaurants · Eaton

Best Bakeries & Desserts in Eaton, CO

4 bakeries & desserts ranked by Google rating and review volume. Updated October 2026.

4Listed
4.7Avg rating
2,560Reviews

Showing 4 of 4

  1. 1. Eaton Ice Cream Shop

    ★★★★★ 4.9 (56 Google reviews)

    Ice Cream Shop · 201 S Elm Ave #2, Eaton

    TakeoutKid friendly

    "Absolutely love this place! Eaton Ice Cream Shop is a true local gem. Family-owned and run with real care, they make their ice cream and popsicles fresh right here-nothing mass-produced or..."

    Todd Richards on Google
  2. 2. Mountain Morsels

    ★★★★★ 5.0 (5 Google reviews)

    Confectionery store · 126 1st St Ste 1, Eaton

    "I have been watching posts on FB for a little while now and decided to stop in and try out the pretty apples. Right when I walked in I was welcomed by a smile and greeting which is rare..."

    Haley Howell on Google
  3. 3. Heritage Market

    ★★★★★ 4.4 (935 Google reviews)

    Supermarket · 180 S Elm Ave, Eaton

    Delivery

    "You would never know that it is small town market!! Great selection!! I also LOVE how they bring my groceries to my car, & load them for me!! It is always a pleasure to shop here!!"

    Deanna Pizzuti on Google
  4. 4. A&W Restaurant

    ★★★★★ 4.3 (1,564 Google reviews)

    Fast Food Restaurant · 680 Oak Ave, Eaton

    TakeoutKid friendly

    "Oh how we love this place. Wife use to come here when she was younger and now we bring our daughter here. The chicken fried steak sandwich is really good, but you have to ask for it as..."

    Jacob Hollen on Google

Bakeries & Desserts in Eaton, CO at a glance

We track 4 bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO, carrying 2,560 Google reviews between them and an average rating of 4.7 stars. Eaton Ice Cream Shop holds the strongest rating among well reviewed spots at 4.9 stars, while A&W Restaurant is the most reviewed with 1,564 reviews.

1 of them open before 7 a.m. on at least one day of the week, including Heritage Market. 4 keep Sunday hours. According to Google, 2 list takeout and 2 list kid friendly.

Several cluster along S Elm Ave, so you can compare a couple of options in one trip.

Questions people ask about bakeries & desserts in Eaton

What is the best rated bakery or dessert shop in Eaton, CO?

Eaton Ice Cream Shop has the highest rating among bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO with at least 25 Google reviews, at 4.9 stars from 56 reviews.

Which bakery or dessert shop in Eaton, CO has the most reviews?

A&W Restaurant has the most Google reviews of any bakery or dessert shop in Eaton, CO, with 1,564 reviews and a 4.3 star average.

Are there bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO open early?

Yes. 1 bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO open before 7 a.m. on at least one day, including Heritage Market. Check each listing for the exact hours.

Do any bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO deliver?

Google lists delivery for 1 bakeries & desserts in Eaton, CO, including Heritage Market.

Listing data, ratings, reviews and photos provided by . Photos remain the property of their credited authors.