Weld County, Colorado

Greeley --° Loading NWS
Claim your listing
Add your business

Restaurants · Greeley

Best Pizza in Greeley, CO

25 pizza ranked by Google rating and review volume. Updated October 2026.

25Listed
4.0Avg rating
15,514Reviews
All restaurantsCoffee ShopsMexican RestaurantsBreakfast & BrunchPizzaBBQ & SteakhousesBakeries & Desserts

Showing 25 of 25

  1. 1. MOD Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.6 (886 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 4365 Centerplace Dr Ste 300, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "Best pizza in Colorado. I love to come here! Their special drinks are great, and so are their pizzas! I highly recommend coming to build your own pizza! My sisters love the salads. The..."

    Jonah LeBaron on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  2. 2. Santeramo's Pizza House and Italian Food

    ★★★★★ 4.5 (1,688 Google reviews)

    Italian Restaurant · $10-20 · 1229 10th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "An excellent little restaurant with incredible food, and a pleasing atmosphere! Very quite and qaint! Pizza is very good, and the garlic bread is the best I have ever had!! Highly recommended!!"

    Christopher Sherrill on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  3. 3. Bulldog Pub & Grub

    ★★★★★ 4.5 (961 Google reviews)

    Bar & Grill · $10-20 · 1815 65th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "First time eating here and food was great! Jordan was our server and she was wonderful and so was all the other staff. We had the new Italian Sushi and it was very good along with all the..."

    Kaleb Schmittler on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  4. 4. Fonta's Pizza Restaurant

    ★★★★★ 4.5 (832 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 2400 8th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Been coming here since I was a baby and like a fine wine, this place has only gotten better with time. Troy and Tracy are wonderful. Love our green olive and sausage pizza along with the..."

    Carrie Duffert on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  5. 5. Empire State Pizza West Greeley

    ★★★★★ 4.5 (237 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 4318 9th St Rd Unit A1, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Kind people here makes eating more enjoyable and the pizza is DELICIOUS and worth the price. Daily lunch specials and evening deals as well. Huge slices and 7pm til close $2 Slices til they..."

    Cheryl Vasquez on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  6. 6. Blackjack Pizza & Salads

    ★★★★★ 4.4 (606 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · 3810 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Absolutely fantastic! I wasn’t planning on ordering and stopped in after shopping nearby I was greeted with a kind smile and the best service you could ask for! She was absolutely..."

    Polly Sholl on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  7. 7. Bravos Philly's & Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.4 (502 Google reviews)

    Greek Restaurant · $10-20 · 1635 8th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "Cashier was eating dinner with his family, but when I entered he did not treat me like I was interrupting him. Instead, in no rush, he took my order with a smile, and was a very nice guy..."

    Nov West on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  8. 8. Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.4 (336 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 6628 W 10th St Suite A, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Magnificent job! Good timing. Walked in when it was done. Ordered and finished in 10 minutes or less during rush hour Tuesday. The pizza was amazing. Thank you so much. Keep up the great..."

    Google Baron on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  9. 9. Roma West

    ★★★★★ 4.2 (579 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 5750 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "This location is cute and right off of tenth street. The hostess greeted us quickly and let my kiddos choose where to sit. That was nice but we chose the back high booth so we could check..."

    Yolanda Marie E. on Google
    CallDirections

  10. 10. Marco's Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.2 (397 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 2000 35th Ave Ste A, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "I came in and the owner was just sitting and chatting with some costumers. The staff was really patient with me as a first time customer and super sweet. The pizza is just the right amount..."

    Arin Hallman on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  11. 11. Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

    ★★★★★ 4.1 (2,054 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 2349 W 29th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "First time here at this location. The thin crust pizza was pretty good. Others in our party had the boneless wings, bacon cheeseburger, and twisted tenders. All were good as I'm told. Place..."

    Keith Kitti on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  12. 12. Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley

    ★★★★★ 4.1 (906 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 728 16th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "So happy this mainstay in downtown Greeley reopened! I love the atmosphere- it oozes college pizza joint in a good way. The retro music posters and ticket stubs on the tables brought back..."

    Mike Aldridge on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  13. 13. The Tavern at St. Michael's Square

    ★★★★★ 4.1 (877 Google reviews)

    Pub · $10-20 · 2918 67th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryOutdoor seatingKid friendly

    "We had a very nice late lunch at the Tavern! The service was excellent! Thank You Mack! Good down home food, nice atmosphere, good music playing! We had a great experience!"

    Bruce Schofield on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  14. 14. Blackjack Pizza & Salads

    ★★★★★ 4.1 (824 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · 814 E 16th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "New to the area and decided to get pizza for my Father’s Day dinner. Got the Sriracha Chicken pizza and the flavors were spot on. I was pleasantly surprised. Ollie? took my phone order and..."

    Foxy on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  15. 15. Domino's Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.1 (405 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · $10-20 · 3521 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDelivery

    "Today is May 24, 2025 - after getting a price of $37.80 from the store just south of this one about 3 miles we decided not to get those two medium pizzas because it was too high. We then..."

    Nate Kennelly on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  16. 16. Domino's Pizza

    ★★★★★ 4.3 (18 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · $10-20 · 1105 11th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDelivery

    "I just want to say that this location has always been so wonderful to us since it opened. We had a incident over the weekend where my Husband ordered some pizza while I was working for him..."

    Alma Vallejo on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  17. 17. D.P. Dough

    ★★★★★ 4.0 (592 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 911 16th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "The employee was so kind and helped me decide what to order and gave me an extra cookie. I was having a rough night, I didn’t catch his name but I really appreciate it, you made my day...."

    Valaesha Martinez on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  18. 18. Papa Johns Pizza

    ★★★★★ 3.9 (235 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 4731 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Fast service with accuracy. Classic Papa John’s taste and quality. I’m always greeted warmly when I enter for a pickup and the team can always handle a curve if I forgot to add a sauce cup..."

    Scott Johnson on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  19. 19. Domino's Pizza

    ★★★★★ 3.9 (449 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · $10-20 · 2412 8th Ave, Greeley

    TakeoutDelivery

    "Alexis was amazing hopefully i spelt her name right, I tried ordering through the ai system and I was a nightmare charged my card then canceled it and transferred me here. She had amazing..."

    Josh R on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  20. 20. Papa Johns Pizza

    ★★★★★ 2.8 (5 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $1-10 · 11701 W 24th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "Went twice to this location and both times the service was poor."

    Jose Felix on Google
    DirectionsWebsite

  21. 21. Domino's

    ★★★★★ 3.5 (97 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · 7008 W 10th St #300, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great customer service and genuinely helpful staff. I accidentally ordered from the wrong location, and a gentleman went out of his way to help-he gave me the correct address and even..."

    Bryce Andrews on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  22. 22. Pizza Hut Express

    ★★★★★ 2.9 (21 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · 4400 Centerplace Dr, Greeley

    Kid friendly

    CallDirectionsWebsite

  23. 23. Pizza Hut

    ★★★★★ 3.5 (689 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · $10-20 · 2439 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDeliveryKid friendly

    "A wonderful location full of caring people! There was a small mistake about a missing drink and they delivered it asap! Amazing work and even better characters highly recommend this location:)"

    Natalie Komleva on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  24. 24. Pizza Hut

    ★★★★★ 3.4 (457 Google reviews)

    Pizza Delivery · $10-20 · 4637 W 29th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDelivery

    "Carryout order, almost home & realize it’s 1/2 gone."

    Somewhere in time on Google
    CallDirectionsWebsite

  25. 25. Little Caesars Pizza

    ★★★★★ 3.3 (861 Google reviews)

    Pizza Restaurant · $10-20 · 3487 W 10th St, Greeley

    TakeoutDelivery

    CallDirectionsWebsite

Pizza in Greeley, CO at a glance

We track 25 pizza in Greeley, CO, carrying 15,514 Google reviews between them and an average rating of 4.0 stars. MOD Pizza holds the strongest rating among well reviewed spots at 4.6 stars, while Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is the most reviewed with 2,054 reviews.

22 stay open past 9 p.m. on at least one night, which helps if you are eating after a game or a late shift. 23 keep Sunday hours. According to Google, 24 list takeout, 24 list delivery and 7 list outdoor seating.

Several cluster along W 10th St, 8th Ave and Centerplace Dr, so you can compare a couple of options in one trip. Where Google lists a price level, $ is the most common at 19 of 21 listings.

Questions people ask about pizza in Greeley

What is the best rated pizza place in Greeley, CO?

MOD Pizza has the highest rating among pizza in Greeley, CO with at least 25 Google reviews, at 4.6 stars from 886 reviews.

Which pizza place in Greeley, CO has the most reviews?

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom has the most Google reviews of any pizza place in Greeley, CO, with 2,054 reviews and a 4.1 star average.

Which pizza in Greeley, CO are open late?

22 pizza in Greeley, CO stay open past 9 p.m. on at least one night, including MOD Pizza, Santeramo's Pizza House and Italian Food and Bulldog Pub & Grub.

Do any pizza in Greeley, CO deliver?

Google lists delivery for 24 pizza in Greeley, CO, including MOD Pizza, Santeramo's Pizza House and Italian Food and Bulldog Pub & Grub.

More in Greeley

Pizza in nearby towns

Listing data, ratings, reviews and photos provided by . Photos remain the property of their credited authors.